Beyond Human Error: Taxonomies and Safety Science by Brendan Wallace

By Brendan Wallace

A ground-breaking new e-book, past Human blunders: Taxonomies and security technology deconstructs the traditional inspiration of “human blunders” and offers an entire new method of injuries and the way they may be avoided. according to learn conducted within the rail, nuclear, and safeguard industries, the authors convey how, via concentrating completely on ”human error,” platforms and sociological elements are often neglected in modern security technology. additionally they argue that the “information processing” view of human cognition, the basis of nearly all of security technology and ergonomics, is hopelessly simplistic and results in useless or maybe erroneous intervention recommendations. Wallace and Ross discover how what they name the “technically rational” view of technological know-how can abate the method of constructing a taxonomy of blunders occasions, and the results this has for the present orthodoxy. In laying out the constraints of the “technically rational” perspective, they truly outline their very own replacement procedure. they start through demonstrating that the construction of trustworthy taxonomies is essential and supply examples of the way they created such taxonomies within the nuclear and rail industries. They pass directly to supply a critique of traditional “frequentist” information and supply coherent, effortless to exploit possible choices. They finish by means of re-analyzing notorious failures reminiscent of theSpace go back and forth Challenger coincidence to illustrate how the “standard” view of those occasions ignores social and dispensed components. The publication concludes with a stimulating and provocative description of the consequences of this new method for safeguard technology, and the social sciences as a complete. whereas supplying a transparent and intelligible advent to the idea of human mistakes and modern considering in safeguard technology, Wallace and Ross mount a problem to the previous orthodoxy and supply a realistic substitute paradigm.

Show description

Read Online or Download Beyond Human Error: Taxonomies and Safety Science PDF

Similar health & safety books

Inherently Safer Chemical Processes, A Life Cycle Approach

Many conventional routes to more secure techniques upload advanced layers--systems that needs to actively interfere, or that require certain working techniques to steer clear of a disaster. Inherently more secure techniques offer chance aid as a integrated attribute of the method. This publication, which incorporates a foreword by means of the world over famous protection professional and the originator of the inherently more secure thought Trevor Kletz, provides the rules and techniques for employing inherently more secure considering from the beginning of the lifestyles cycle to the very finish.

Introduction to Health and Safety at Work, Second Edition: The handbook for students on NEBOSH and other introductory H&S courses

Creation to healthiness and defense at paintings has been constructed for the NEBOSH nationwide common certificates in Occupational defense and wellbeing and fitness, permitted through the skills and Curriculum Authority, and heavily suits the syllabus. The profitable first version has additionally discovered prepared recognition for different NVQ point three and four classes in well-being and defense.

The Non-halogenated Flame Retardant Handbook

A result of emphasis on exchanging halogenated flame retardants with trade applied sciences, this instruction manual includes in a single position the entire present advertisement non-halogenated flame retardant applied sciences, in addition to experimental platforms close to commercialization. This ebook specializes in non-halogenated flame retardants in a holistic yet sensible demeanour.

Construction hazardous materials compliance guide : lead detection, abatement, and inspection procedures

Thousands of houses equipped prior to 1978 comprise lead paint which poses a major risk to kids below the age of six. building Worksite Compliance advisor: Lead solutions the most typical questions about the necessities as mandated through the EPA's Renovate, fix and portray (RRP) rule and OSHA law 29CFR 1926.

Additional resources for Beyond Human Error: Taxonomies and Safety Science

Example text

Or, perhaps the driver simply wanted the money because he wanted to go on a vacation, which invites the question of why he wanted to go on a vacation (perhaps this was because of the new management) and so on.

It is also clear that in theory any event could function as either a cause or a consequence. For example, imagine a man knocked down by a truck. Now, we discover that the driver crashed because he fell asleep. So, now we decide that this is the root cause. However, we then discover that due to his shift patterns he had been unable to gain an adequate amount of sleep. The fact that he was tired (and subsequently fell asleep) is both a cause of the accident and a consequence of the fact that he had been overworking.

Should we punish human error (as Heinrich argued)? Or, should we (as Gerald Wilde [28] argued from within the school of risk homeostasis) reward the lack of error? These questions demonstrate Putnam’s [see 17] point: in the real world, facts and values are intertwined, rarely more so than in discussions of safety. TR presupposes that facts and values can be separated. Safety and Science 15 When there is fundamental disagreement about means and ends, Schön argued that TR (what we called Platonic or Newtonian science) breaks down because this implies a discussion about values, politics, and morality, and these are topics technical rationalists are particularly ill equipped to discuss (remember that TR deals only with facts, not with values).

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.15 of 5 – based on 22 votes